Valentine's Day Special: 5 Cars We'll Always Love (Because They Never Let Us Down!)
Valentine’s Day isn’t just about flowers and chocolates – it’s about celebrating the relationships that actually last. And while some cars are all style and no substance, others are loyal, dependable and quietly get on with the job, year after year.
To create this list, we blended the most popular "safe bet" cars - according to google search trends - with the highest-ranking vehicles from our MotorEasy Reliability Index. After all, the perfect partner needs to be someone you're attracted to and someone you can rely on.
This Valentine’s Day, we’re celebrating the cars that don’t break your heart - or the bank. Cars that just simply serve their purpose, stick around when it get’s difficult, and prove reliability really does matter.
Here are five cars we truly love, and not just because they look good – but because they are reliable enough to commit to the long haul!
1. Toyota Corolla – The Quiet Supporter
Reliability Score: 9.3
The Toyota Corella is the definition of a low-drama relationship. Ranking an impressive 9.3 on our Reliability scale, it’s the kind of car that doesn’t demand constant attention – and the data backs it up.
When issues do arise, they tend to be manageable, with engine repairs averaging £200, and braking systems coming in at £186. At the higher end of the scale, gearbox issues average around £600 but they’re far from common – reinforcing the Corolla’s reputation for durability.
As one of the best-selling cars of the century – the Corolla has earned its status through consistency. It’s inexpensive to run, straightforward to repair and resistant to ageing. Whether it’s a daily commute or a longer journey, the Corolla just gets on with it.
Why We Love It:
Because it starts every morning without excuses – and keeps repair costs simple.
2. Lexus RX – Luxury That Actually Commits
Reliability Score: 8.4
Luxury cars don’t always have the best reputation when it comes to reliability – but the Lexus RX is a clear exception. Scoring a strong 8.4 on the reliability scale, the Lexus RX proves premium comfort doesn’t always come with eye-watering repair bills.
Looking at our data, the most common claims relate to suspension (38.1%) and brake systems (33.3%), but these tend to be very manageable, with repair costs averaging up to £450.
Built on Toyota-backed engineering, the RX brings long-term dependability, making it far less stressful to own than its rivals. It’s also proof reliability doesn’t have to be exclusive.
Why We Love It:
Because it delivers a premium experience while keeping reliability – and running costs – in check.
3. Honda Civic – The One That Grows On You
Reliability Score: 8.3
The Honda Civic is the dependable partner that adapts to every stage of life. Ranking a solid 8.3 on our reliability scale, it’s a car that quietly proves its worth over time.
First car? No problem. Growing family? Still works. Long-distance commuter? Absolutely. The Civic takes it all in stride without complaint. Renowned for its ability to handle high mileage without a fuss, it’s practical and an economical choice to live with. Our data shows the most common claims relate to the braking system (£29%), but these are also the least expensive repairs – averaging around £140.
Why We Love It:
It’s in it for the long haul – and just keeps giving.
4. Mazda MX-5 – The Fun Favourite
Reliability Score: 8.4
Who says reliability has to be boring? With a reliability score of 8.4, the Mazda MX-5 proves that fun and dependability can coexist.
Built to be lightweight, agile and purely to make driving enjoyable, the MX-5 delivers smiles without the stress usually associated with sports cars. Even better, average repair costs typically come in below £500, making it a surprisingly budget-friendly option for something so entertaining.
Why We Love It:
Because it does what you need it too - and looks good while doing it.
5. Hyundai I30 – The Dependable One
Reliability Score: 8.9
The Hyundai i30 might not scream for attention, but with an impressive 8.9 reliability score, it quietly gets the important things right. Designed for everyday life, it’s spacious, comfortable and packed with useful features, without demanding much in return.
The data in our Reliability Index reflects low-stress ownership. Braking system claims are the most common (53%), yet repairs remain affordable averaging £199. Engine, gearbox and electrical issues are relatively uncommon and cost below £300 on average, making the I30 a cheaper alternative to it’s revivals.
Hyundai’s reputation has soared in recent years, and the i30 is a big reason why. With sensible repair costs and consistent performance, it’s a car built to be dependable every day.
Why We Love It:
Because it shows up when it matters.
Signs Your Car is a Keeper:
A flashy, high-performance car might grab your attention, but when it comes to long-term satisfaction, reliability is what really matters.
Just like any good relationship, you can tell when your car is in it for the long run. If your car ticks most of these boxes, you may have found a keeper:
- I’s dependable – starting reliably, even on those cold, icy mornings.
- It’s predictable – no mystery warning lights or sudden breakdowns.
- It’s low maintenance – services and repairs are predictable and affordable.
- It fits your life – adapting to new jobs, routes and life changes.
- It gives you confidence – you trust it to get you where you need to go.
If your car ticks these boxes, it’s clearly built to go the distance - and worth looking after properly.
Love Your Car Back This Valentine’s Day:
Even the most reliable cars need a little TLC from time to time. While we can predict how frequent and expensive your repairs might be, the unexpected can always happen.
This Valentine’s, show your car some love with MotorEasy:
Car Warranty - Protection against unexpected electrical and mechanical failures, giving you peace of mind if something goes wrong.
GAP Insurance – Covers the financial shortfall if your car is written off due to an accident, theft or damage – an unpleasant surprise no one wants.
Get a GAP Insurance Quote
Servicing and MOT packages – Reliability deserves support. Treat your car to a full manufacturer’s service and get an MOT on us! The perfect way to make sure your car is running smoothly behind the scenes!
Because reliability doesn’t happen by accident. With the right protection and regular care, you can keep your car running smoothly, avoid costly surprises, and enjoy complete peace of mind - long after Valentine’s Day is over!
